add to wish list | library


8 of 8 recommend this,
would you recommend it?

yes | no

Support this site by purchasing from these vendors using the paid links below. As an Amazon Associate SA-CD.net earns from qualifying purchases.
 
amazon.ca
amazon.co.uk
amazon.com
amazon.de
 
amazon.fr
amazon.it
 
jpc

Discussion: Bach: Complete Organ Works - Kooiman, Gremmel-Geuchen, Gnann, Klapprott

Posts: 26
Page: prev 1 2 3

Post by JohnProffitt September 18, 2013 (21 of 26)
Although slightly off topic, it should be noted that Bach was more directly involved in the work of Zacharias Hildebrandt than with Gottfried Silbermann. Hildebrandt's masterwork, the 3-manual organ of St. Wenceslaus in Naumburg, probably had significant design input from Bach. The organ has one 32' stop, a Posaune, and was intended (by Bach?) to have a second 32', an Untersatz, for which a draw-stop knob was installed at the keyboard. Unfortunately, the casework for the organ, which was retained from an earlier instrument, turned out to be too small to accommodate the large flue stop, which ended up not being built.

But yes, indeed, Bach loved his "Gravität" in the sound of the organ. Another example of this is the Herbst organ in Lahm, Germany, where a nephew of J S was organist. Again, it is likely that J S had input into the design of the organ, which is two manuals and 29 stops, one of which is a pedal 32' Posaune!

Post by Fugue November 15, 2013 (22 of 26)
I bought a copy from JAV, which arrived yesterday, and I must say, it's pretty great! No, the bass doesn't cause structural damage to my house or cause my cat to search for shelter, but it is deep enough to be satisfying. The Silbermann organs have quite a bit more clarity than typical large French organs. The performances seem perfectly fine to my ears, although I did not have time to listen to all 19 discs yesterday! The sonics are outstanding--extremely detailed and clear but with plenty of (natural) reverb to give a solid sense of space.

Post by Fugue November 16, 2013 (23 of 26)
My set arrived a few days ago. I have to say that JAV is not very responsive to emails and it took a while to arrive, but it's all good now. And so is this recording! Those used to hearing Bach on massive French organs with 32' pipes might be a *little* disappointed, but what those Silbermann organs lack in pure thunder make up for it in spades with clarity--besides, isn't the music more important than the hi-fi effects? Anyway, the 16' foot pipes produce a perfectly satisfying amount of bass. I have listened only to two discs so far, but the playing is superb, and the sound is just fantastic.

Post by Polarius T November 16, 2013 (24 of 26)
Great to hear; that is pretty much what I am looking forward to with this particular set (ordered it finally some days ago with a 20% welcome-back discount from a certain independent German site with a ridiculously low intra-Europe S&H, which is also one of the non-Amazon sponsors of this site).

The wait for a Bach organ set with a truly hi-fi SQ has been a long one for me, so I hope I've finally found a modern equivalent to the otherwise immortal Helmut Walcha DG recordings I've loved since I first heard them.

Post by Lute February 28, 2014 (25 of 26)
I finally decided to take the plunge and get a copy of this set. It was worth the wait and $€£¥... It will be a while before I get through all 19 disks. As others have commented, the sonics and performances are first class. Stocks seem to be a little low with dealers. Those interested shouldn't wait too long, I guess. Next I'll be looking forward to the continuation of CPO's Pachelbel series.

Post by souwestman February 28, 2014 (26 of 26)
Got my copy recently - need to find the time to play but I am very excited about exploring the set

Page: prev 1 2 3

Closed