add to wish list | library


20 of 21 recommend this,
would you recommend it?

yes | no

Support this site by purchasing from these vendors using the paid links below. As an Amazon Associate SA-CD.net earns from qualifying purchases.
 
amazon.ca
amazon.co.uk
amazon.com
amazon.de
 
amazon.fr
amazon.it
 
 

Discussion: Steve Reich: Music for 18 Musicians - GVSU New Music Ensemble

Posts: 7

Post by Beagle May 19, 2009 (1 of 7)
Here's a wake-up call for those of you who missed Christine's, Polly's and Geohominid's reviews.

Christine says some may find this intricate, hypnotic music 'infuriating' -- but I've never met those people. I hope the word 'accessible' doesn't have a condescending odour, because this is a sonic world that is easier to get into than to escape. I suspect all of us on this site happily admit to being "audiophiles". Well, there's an amazing load of audio to phile on this disc.

Post by vincefalks August 22, 2009 (2 of 7)
That is a great review by Christine.

Steve Reich is my favorite composer and musician of all time, I love him very much and practically deify his music. This piece is my favorte piece of all time, and THIS recording, wow! Musically, it is on par with the nonesuch 1998, and sonically - WOW! It is such a well-recorded and mastered disc that I did not know it wasn't pure DSD until discovering that detail here.

Anyway, after Christine's great review there's not much needed to be said about this disc - her bottom line at the end is exactly what I would say. And on top of her recommendation, I say that every person on this planet simply must give their ears a chance of hearing this piece...

I feel it is one of those classical pieces of music which anyone of almost any genre preference can likely appreciate. Of all the classical movements and "sub-genres", minimalism is one of the most "non-classical, and of Reich's music, Music for 18 Musicians is his most loved and most accessible work. The result, is something that can speak to anybody and when I recommend this piece to my rock-loving friends, I don't say it is classical music but I compare it more to ambience, electronic and really, it is closer to Balanese gamelan and African music than it is to Mozart.

This SACD is my new holy grail recording for Music for 18 Musicians. It is in such wonderful quality, and in surround to boot. What better a piece to immerse myself in than this piece! And musically, it satisfies me as much as the Nonesuch. However I still like to get out the nonesuch from time to time. It does have some things about it that the GVSU one does lack. But GVSU has some things I like about it than Nonesuch also lacks.....such as better timing between the musicians. They spent a year rehearsing the piece and it shows. Not that that's a hugely important point.....

BTW....while this piece may have been used for advertisements for headache pills, I once saw it used for an official youtube advertisement promoting some youtube world peace day about a year ago! Such is the duality, or polarity, of Reich's aesthetic. Another "dual" aspect of his music which I find remarkable, is that it is both exciting and relaxing for me. It's like this ecstatic trance which can be both hypnotic, AND/OR euphoric.

Ok I'll stop now...I could go on forever about this man and his music!

Post by diw August 22, 2009 (3 of 7)
You sold me on it, just ordered a copy

Post by Edvin August 22, 2009 (4 of 7)
I actually prefer the ECM version.

Post by telemak May 11, 2010 (5 of 7)
However, sounds like a PCM recording it is...

Post by Beagle May 11, 2010 (6 of 7)
telemak said: However, sounds like...
NEW MUSIC ENSEMBLE:
"For our fall 2006 concert we performed Steve Reich's masterpiece, Music for 18 Musicians, in honor of the composer's seventieth birthday.... On a whim I sent our concert tape of last semester to Innova Recordings. They were thoroughly impressed and wanted us to re-record for a 2007 release. This will only be the fifth commercial recording of the work, and the FIRST in 5.1 surround. All-star engineer Silas Brown flew in from New York to handle the sessions. We recorded over three long, grueling days in beautiful Royce Auditorium of St Cecelia's Music Society in Grand Rapids, MI." http://www.newmusicensemble.org/page4/page4.html

COLOPHON:
Executive Producer: Bill Ryan
Session Producer and Engineer: Silas Brown
Assistant Engineer: Chester Gwazda
Edited, Mixed and Mastered by Silas Brown and Bill Ryan
Recorded at Royce Auditorium, St Cecilia's Music Center, Grand Rapids MI
Edited, Mixed and Mastered at Legacy Sound Studios, New Rochelle NY
DSD Transfer Engineer and SACD Authoring: Graemme Brown at Zen Mastering, Vancouver

SA-CD.NET REVIEWS:
Christine Tham 5+5 stars
Geohominid: 5+5 stars
Polly Nomial: 5+5 stars

MORE RAVE REVIEWS:
http://innova.mu/artist1.asp?skuID=303

Post by airegin May 11, 2010 (7 of 7)
Music for 18 Musicians - GVSU New Music Ensemble.

I've had it for awhile and it's good. I would not say it's five stars on a five scale. The students did a fine job playing the music, but the recording quality IMO is more like a three and a half. With respect to those other knowledgeable reviewers.

Actually I prefer the selection of Reich on my RBCD: Reich Exclusive Selection, Nonesuch WPCR-19002 (which is a Japanese pressing).

Closed